Monday, 18 August 2008

Holy Smoke and More Smoke Arising

In a story over at Holy Smoke, Damian Thompson writes the below article on the Bishop of Lancaster's condemnation of the Bishops' Conference of England and Wales. I have not read the document nor do I know anything about the bishop that Mr. Thompson is reporting. I am simply interested in the dynamics of how the "story" is being presented. According to the story, the Bishop is about to retire and has written a document criticising the "divergent views" of bishops within the Conference. It is written with an element of surprise that a bishop is teaching the Truth of the Catholic Faith, e.g. 'traditional views'. My question would be why a document like this at this point when he is coming to retirement? As one who holds to the Church's teaching on these controversial issues surrounding sexuality, surely these criticisms were brought up prior to his imminent retirement? Is there simply a lot of sensationalism to this story and the others about which are presently being reported? If things are as the report suggests, the issues sound, oh, so familiar to these Anglican ears. Does anyone know where the document will be published and who will be reading it? Is it for the general public?
The Bishop of Lancaster, the Rt Rev Patrick O'Donoghue, will mark his retirement this month with a review of the state of the Catholic Church that strongly criticises the Bishops' Conference of England and Wales for its "divergent views" and failure to uphold Church teaching on same-sex couples. The bishop, who recently deplored the state of Catholic education in a teaching document, says his colleagues seemed "surprised" that he had spoken out in defence of traditional values.

He attacks the way the Bishops' Conference bureaucracy divides major issues into "areas of responsibility" for particular bishops, leaving other bishops "reluctant ... to speak out on these issues, as if somehow they had handed over their competence in these areas to the responsible bishops and his particular committee".

And he adds: "I must register, too, my disappointment that our Bishops' Conference recently could not agree a collegial response to the Government's legislation on same-sex adoption."

The Conference's statements, says Bishop O'Donoghue, tend to be "flat and safe at a time when we need passionate and courageous public statements that dare to speak the full truth in love".

I should emphasise that the bishop's stinging criticism forms only a small part of a long and thought-provoking 92-page report, A Fit for Mission Church: Being Catholic Today, which will be published on August 27. It is a deeply impressive document that puts to shame the vapid pronouncements of the other Catholic bishops of England and Wales.

Bishop O'Donoghue's remarks, together with the outcry over the shocking behaviour of the Diocese of Leeds in closing much-loved churches, should give us grounds for hope.

At long last, the Magic Circle of liberal bishops – who set up the Church's waffling Left-wing bureaucracy – is coming under serious pressure. Now we need an Archbishop of Westminster who will break it up and liberate the faithful.

Comments on "Holy Smoke and More Smoke Arising"

 

Blogger Andrew Teather said ... (18 August 2008 21:14) : 

I know that he writes in an attractive way, but I really should not pay too much attention to the ravings of the madman in the attic. (Damian, that is).

 

Blogger Christian said ... (19 August 2008 11:28) : 

That is not quite fair. He just says what most RC's feel on the inside. I love his work because seminarians and clerics cannot say these things in our Church. It is nice that he is standing up for the rights of the laity.

 

Blogger Fr. Jeffrey Steel said ... (19 August 2008 11:36) : 

Why do you say that Andrew?

 

Anonymous Anonymous said ... (19 August 2008 12:44) : 

Andrew - Damian does get carried away sometimes it is true. And he is well capable of putting the knife in - and then turning it. But thank God he is prepared to speak out and is willing to cut through the cant and humbug served up by "official spokespeople" both clerical and lay. Besides, some of his "tit-bits" about the in-fighting between senior clerics brightens the day!

On a serious note I think Damian doesn't always appreciate the strains and conflicts faced by Bishops and others in positions of leadership.Their desire to keep the peace/not rock the boat etc is understandable even if sometimes misguided. But it is important Damian stays around and continues to expose that which should be exposed.

Oh yes, the Bishop of Lancaster sounds like a good man!

 

Blogger Andrew Teather said ... (19 August 2008 18:11) : 

I quite agree, Damian's writings are almost always entertaining and sometimes enlightening, but he has two very large chips on his shoulders, firstly the English Bishops Conference and secondly the Anglican Church. Bashing either of these institutions certainly seems to come before coherence and journalistic integrity.

I mention attic, as he works from a most interesting attic in the City, which I commend to you. He makes a delightful companion for lunch, however.

 

Anonymous Joseph said ... (19 August 2008 18:48) : 

" He just says what most RC's feel on the inside. " Really? Or just a few intolerant ones who happen to be very voacl and very destructive?

 

Blogger Christian said ... (19 August 2008 19:32) : 

Very few (except some brown-nosers) have much respect for the Bishops Conference. What have they done that has actually helped anything in the church? By that I mean REALLY help. Helped enough to warrant the amount time and money wasted on it.

Granted most RC's don't think badly of the Anglicans of today (they universally dislike the ones during penal times). Most of them don't really care much about it.

 

post a comment